Man Madhan Ambu

This is one of the two allegedly up-market watch-this-film-if-you-want-to-be-known-as-intelligent films I watched last weekend (the other one is Dhobi Ghat and that’s coming very soon here). For now, it’s just Mannaar, MadanaGopal and Ambujaakshi!

Image Courtesy:

This is a Kamal Haasan film. Kamal Hassan has written the story, screenplay and dialogues for this film, making it for at an audience of a different league (at least, reportedly).Well, it must have been. For I wasn’t so awed at it, to say the least. let’s delve in.

There is comedy. Some fantastic lines. The film is around and about stereotypical suspecting fiances, cruel mothers of these fiances, divorced friends, bed-ridden partners and their tear-stricken wives.

Ambu (played rather un-annoyingly by Trisha, for her own good) is an independent successful woman of today who speaks ‘Anglo-Tamil’ (as she herself calls it) for acceptance and writes (or reads or whatever) Tamil poetry in her free time. She loves the man in her life but can’t particularly give up her career for him. They all talk about her being smart and sharp and all, I wonder what makes them think so. Throughout the film, she is so beautifully led by the people around her!

Major Mannaar (the Kamal Hassan who looks far from the charming self) ‘lies’ to his boss to save his friend’s life and the whole film is a comedy of lies. It is so predictable what this man would say (may be not so much) and do (for sure) next. You just know what’s going to happen next. As an ex-army man, a current detective, a widower, a French speaking widower, as Kamal Haasan..where is the charm, I say?

Madana Gopal (a drunk Madhavan who makes me think he accepted this film only because it was Kamal’s) is after his girlfriend’s life in sheer suspicion. Under the able guidance of his mother (who is the vamp, by the way), he hires a detective to spy on his girlfriend. Fantastic! But he sits in front of the TV and watches what’s called ‘emotional atyachar’ and passes crass comments about it. He is totally drunk for a good part of the film and after a point, isn’t funny anymore!

Deepa (played by Sangeetha, whose children are named Bhagirathi and Vishwanathan, in traditional Indian ways, but are called “bags” and “Vish” anyway!) has some of the best lines in the film. But the climax scene of getting drunk and “loving” Madan is totally tasteless! The young boy being told untrue things about his mother in the toilet…Nah! I’ll pass that!

Kunju Kurup and Manju Kurup practically speak Malayalam throughout the film. Why, may I ask? Oh yes, they are Malayalis! Too bad that the audiences (like me) don’t know Malayalam.

I don’t even want to talk about Ramesh Aravind and Urvashi in the film. Totally wasted!

Most certainly, the film is not all bad. It was indeed an entertaining watch and a lot of things must have contributed to that. For a start, Kamal Haasan has written some brilliant lines. From whatever little I recall, Deepa in a scene says “the matrimony was lousy. But the alimony was super”, summing her character up, all in one line (It’s not a judgement I am passsing)!

Some poignant lines of irony “Enakku cleara oru vazhi theiryudhu ma” [I see a clear way ahead] in a scene where Mannaar has walked in to a dead end and “nadutheruvula ukkandirukken” [I am sitting in the middle of the road] in a scene where he is literally sitting in the middle of the road.

In a scene, he says (something to the effect of), “Thappu panravangalukku thimiru kattupudi aagaadhu. Aana nermaiyaanavangalukku thimir than veli” [For people who are making mistakes, arrogance is not affordable. For the honest, arrogance is the protective fence]. Such an interesting thought that (certainly may have been said before. But I first heard it from him)!

“Ellaathayum vida veeramaana vishayam ahimsai. Idhu enakku modhallaye thrinjirundha naan ivlo kolaigal panni irukkave maaten” [Non-violence is the purest expression of valour. Had I known this before, I’d never have killed all the people I did (as an Army Major).] : A political statement about military and defence after all the ones about capital punishment, socialism, religion among others.

The song that’s shot backwards is a commendable effort as a song and as a narration technique. It’s a story told in less that 5 minutes and told so effectively that I know more from the song than from the whole film, I guess.

In the end, it’s the lines that make me want to watch the film again. I perhaps will when the DVD is out. But what scares me most is having to go through the last hour of badly executed Crazy Mohan like comedy! Chaos that isn’t particularly tickling. It’s a very interesting watch! It’s not one bit a rib tickling comedy! May be it wasn’t meant to be!

P.S: There is one other thing that has been ringing in my head. The brand positioning of Fortis Hospitals in the film. There are logos, references and all sorts of ways to tell the audience about Fortis in almost all hospital scenes (Ramesh Arvind’s and Kamal’s wife’s). Awesome! I know now that Fortis does Chemotherapy! But, have they noticed that throughout the film Urvashi cries that the doctor’s wouldn’t operate on Ramesh Aravind (sorry for not remembering character names) if they were not given apparently huge sums of money. I think of Fortis as money making machines with absolutely no regard for human life! Is it just me? Or is it really brand positioning gone awfully wrong?

Man Madhan Ambu

8 thoughts on “Man Madhan Ambu

  1. Salar Mohamed Bijili says:

    I also watched the movie sometime back and felt its a lazily done movie with completely disinterested actors. I fail to understand where is the Kamal sir of anbesivam and virumaandi gone?. By making such mediocre movies he is only damaging his own reputation.

  2. It’s more of an expectation problem as against a reputation problem. There is enough literature on the internet that talks about how Kamal Haasan is a pseudo intellectual and most of his films are straight rip-offs of films from other languages. (I am NOT saying this. I am only quoting other bloggers. I can’t recollect names to link them here. Will look up.) This thought is also largely true.
    May be we should look beyond idolising Kamal Haasan and looking at other people who are contributing to Tamil cinema as well.

  3. Salar Mohamed Bijili says:

    Partly disagree with the ‘pseudo intellectual’ bit. Kamal sir has made subtle yet strong performances in many movies(atleast till mid 90s). Its only from the beginning of this decade that he started believing that people would watch whatever he makes. Aalavandhan, dasa for eg. . . Even though anbe sivam was a shameless ripoff and went over the head of many of his fans, i would say its a decent attempt, albeit too intellectual :)

    Coming to tamil cinema industry,Last 3 yrs have seen lots of new faces but what remains to be seen is how many do survive and perform consistently. One should appreciate the faith producers have in these new chaps. Such trend was not noticed in the 90s. Moreover audience taste and expectations have changed drastically. Innovation and freshness are welcome today in Tamil cinema

  4. I somewhat liked Aalavandhan. Not in a way that I think it’s a greta film. But I think it was a decent attempt with really interesting subtext. Anbe Sivam was a good film. I can still watch the film for the zillionth time in my life. It has a new meaning every time I watch it. I don’t think it is too intellectual! May be a wee bit ahead a time?
    I don’t see the need for any of these youngsters to survive. I mean one great film and they can all move on with their lives. They don’t have to perform consistently. The rate at which youngsters and new faces are coming in to the industry, it is very likely that most of them will never be seen again. But that is okay. It’s best when cinema is about the film and not about the people, you know?

  5. Did not like this movie at all .. Had high expectations after I saw Madhavan and Kamal in it but they fail to deliver the magic they delivered in Anbe Sivam .. In the end it seems more like a Priyadarshan Hindi movie with so many confusions.

    But have to agree that the dialogues are really good .. The entire scene where Trisha tells Kamal that she was the one driving the car – The dialogue that follows is superb ..

    The Neela Vaanam song is wonderful ! Love the way it has been picturized .. :)

    1. I agree. I guess Kamal is glorified for no reason that we expect wonders from him every time. He is obsessed with being different and so we are hurt with pieces like Dasaavathaaram! :P

  6. smitha says:

    Absolutely lousy film. There was a song penned by kamal ridiculing (as usual) Hindu Gods & Godesses in the most obscene way. Thankfully, it was removed by the producer before the release after protests by hindu organisations.

    Deserved to miserably flop & it did.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s